It's the other guy's paradigm, not mine!
Interesting how people at the University of Hawaii view the Mists of Ramanna. From an official university page:
"It addresses the theory that a 'Kingdom of Ramanna' in Lower Burma, the foundations for early Burma and Mainland Southeast Asia scholarship for over a hundred years, is a myth. It is essentially an ethnic interpretation of history."
What does "it" refer to? Aung-thwin or the Mon Paradigm? This summary exhibits the same confusion that almost everyone exhibits when first confronted by the Mon Paradigm:
Honest-question: Is the Mon Paradigm Michael Aung-thwin's theory?
Honest-answer: No, well actually yes, in a way:
1. It is specially constructed by Aung-thwin to be wrong.
2. It is placed in the mouths of other historians to discredit them.
So yes, it sort of is his theory.
Professor of FUD Michael Aung-thwin at work again, keeping up the good fight for the Myanmar Junta, even using their tactics.
Daw Aung San Suu Kyi is a terrorist, right? And every historian of Burma except Michael Aung-thwin and friends (and you damn well better be one, no criticizing my theories, or else...) is a Mon Paradigmist!
"It addresses the theory that a 'Kingdom of Ramanna' in Lower Burma, the foundations for early Burma and Mainland Southeast Asia scholarship for over a hundred years, is a myth. It is essentially an ethnic interpretation of history."
What does "it" refer to? Aung-thwin or the Mon Paradigm? This summary exhibits the same confusion that almost everyone exhibits when first confronted by the Mon Paradigm:
Honest-question: Is the Mon Paradigm Michael Aung-thwin's theory?
Honest-answer: No, well actually yes, in a way:
1. It is specially constructed by Aung-thwin to be wrong.
2. It is placed in the mouths of other historians to discredit them.
So yes, it sort of is his theory.
Professor of FUD Michael Aung-thwin at work again, keeping up the good fight for the Myanmar Junta, even using their tactics.
Daw Aung San Suu Kyi is a terrorist, right? And every historian of Burma except Michael Aung-thwin and friends (and you damn well better be one, no criticizing my theories, or else...) is a Mon Paradigmist!
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home